Bishop v Indonesian Ambassador Kesoema. Who said what and who is lying?

Margo Kingston

Margo Kingston

Co-publisher and editor-in-chief at No Fibs
Margo Kingston is a retired Australian journalist and climate change activist. She is best known for her work at The Sydney Morning Herald and her weblog, Webdiary. Since 2012, Kingston has been a citizen journalist, reporting and commenting on Australian politics via Twitter and No Fibs.
Margo Kingston
- 3 weeks ago
Margo Kingston
Asylum-seekers arrive at Christmas Island. Source: The Australian

Asylum-seekers arrive at Christmas Island. Source: The Australian

What the Indonesian Ambassador said about Coalition’s turn-back-boats policy:

Ambassador Nadjib Riphat Kesoema said Indonesia would welcome Tony Abbott or whoever leads Australia after the September election.

But he said asylum seeker boats should be turned back to other countries, not to Indonesia.

“Indonesia is a transit country and also the victim of this situation. I think it’s not possible for the coalition to say that it has to go back to Indonesia because Indonesia is not the origin country of these people,” he told reporters in Canberra on Friday.

“No such collaboration will happen between Indonesia and Australia (to) bring back the people to Indonesia.”

The opposition has long promised to end the flood of asylum seeker arrivals with its three-strand policy of offshore processing of asylum seekers, re-introducing temporary protection visas and turning back asylum seeker boats.

Although the coalition policy has been on the table for a number of years, Mr Kesoema said it had never been discussed with Indonesia.

“I don’t think that this issue will be aired by Mr Abbott,” he said. – AAP

Below is a collection of tweets establishing the discrepancy between what the Ambassador said was discussed in meetings between the Opposition and Indonesia and what Ms Bishop is on the record of saying. One of them is lying. They can’t both be right. Judge for yourself.



Read more:

Tony Abbott ‘a mouse in Indonesia’

Visit to Indonesia, Tony Abbott, Julia Gillard

No boat turnbacks, Indonesia says

Julie Bishop, Indonesia, boats and Guardian Australia

Guardian beat up

Julie Bishop must explain or apologise for Indonesia comments, says Labor

Personal explanation to Parliament by Julie Bishop

Labor wants Julie Bishop referred to standards committee


Support an independent media voice. Support No Fibs Citizen Journalism.
Monthly Donation



Comments


  1. Bishop v Indonesian Ambassador Kesoema. Who said what and who is lying? http://t.co/ZENpEWMJXb


  2. Bishop v Indonesian Ambassador Kesoema. Who sai… http://t.co/Uu8DxfjFrH


  3. How much funding from Macquarie Dictionary is funnelled to this site Margot?

  4. margokingston says

    CORRECTION: Julie Bishop did issue a press statement yesterday. My google searches did not reveal it. Apologies. Here is her personal explanation in Parliament yesterday. Note that like her statement does not address the key issues – did she have assurances that Indonesia would accept turned-back boats, and did she stand by her dismissal of the Ambassador’s denial that the matter had ever been discussed with the Indonesians.

    http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;db=CHAMBER;id=chamber%2Fhansardr%2F9526da6b-9674-4509-a6d5-a7115a7c1f1a%2F0148;query=Id%3A%22chamber%2Fhansardr%2F9526da6b-9674-4509-a6d5-a7115a7c1f1a%2F0000%22


  5. Bishop v Indonesian Ambassador Kesoema. Who said what and who is lying? http://t.co/UhgdXskfJT #auspol


  6. Bishop v Indonesian Ambassador Kesoema. Who said what and who is lying? http://t.co/UkfhGO8D9i: http://t.co/VsyHxmFpTf Is she or isn’t she?