Supreme confusion reigns among our esteemed media on the story, the players, their roles and the status of information released by the Government today. The Government claims that earlier performed departmental costings and modelling of the Coalition’s policies showed that they are likely to produce a $10 Billion black hole. Below is a quick summary of what happened today.
Before we get to that, here is an idea that may be unoriginal and crazy but worth raising: How about Treasury releases the Red Book and Blue Book publicly before the election? This should be able to provide the best available advice, assessment and information about both major parties policy platforms that a sophisticated and wealthy country like ours can afford. A definitive and expert report, with exception of security and other privileged information, that an incoming Government has to rely upon should form the basis of the ideas debate in a healthy and informed democracy.
What do you think? Read below how easily our media gets lost without expert and independent input from Twitter.
Coalition 10 billion blackhole and media reports
Supreme confusion reigns among our esteemed media on the story, players and subject of Govt claims and departmental reports of a Coalition 10 Billion Blackhole. Here is a quick primer on what happened today. Let’s start with "Subjects and Verbs and Objects" – Basic Sentence Unit in English
-
-
-
Maybe it is time to release the actual PBO costings then? Surely that would clear it all up?
-
Treasury & Finance dept secretaries effectively slap down Govt for using them in costings row. @sbsnews 6.30pm & here tinyurl.com/o7kml55
-
Statement on Costings by the Department of the Treasury and the Department of Finance and DeregulationJoint media release with the Department of Finance and Deregulation There have been a series of reports today regarding costings undertak…
-
Treasury doc scandal is a disgrace.Someone has to fall on a sword. Can’t be PMRudd so…Treasurer Bowen?Minister Wong? Or staffers? #auspol
-
The @pbo_au isn’t saying that the costing is wrong @Kieran_Gilbert just that it is not the formal costing of a policy lodged by LNP
-
That @joehockey @andrewrobbmp haven’t fronted a full press conference on LNP costings today is telling. What are they hiding?
-
To the contrary @jamesmassola has seriously misstated the role of impartial public servants @michellegrattan @ConversationEDU
-
Both implying public servants are in effect being political – untrue and gross misreading of statements @jamesmassola @michellegrattan
-
Kevin Rudd claims $10bn hole in Coalition’s costings, public servants disagreeTWO of Australia’s most senior public servants have undermined Labor claims of a $10 billion black hole in Tony Abbott’s election costing…
-
LNP have failed to meet 5.30pm deadline today set by @pbo_au for costing election policies (p.4): aph.gov.au/~/media/05{17ac88c265afb328fa89088ab635a2a63864fdefdd7caa0964376053e8ea14b3}20Abo… #epicfail
-
Labor’s fiscal credibility in absolute tatters. Unprecedented move by Treasury & Finance to distance themselves from Labor’s lies. #ausvotes
-
LNP line on costings tonight is that the Australian people should trust them, they don’t need to know the truth. Good luck with that one!
-
@TonyAbbottMHR @JoeHockey @AndrewRobbMP @MathiasCormann failed to meet deadline set by @PBO_AU for costing election policies. Comments?
-
A quick clarifier on this arvo’s costings arsehattery.
-
1.Government costed swathes of known & likely Coalition policies before the election – all governments do.Part of the power of incumbency
-
2. Government released some of those costings today – media fails completely to understand the process involved with the costings
-
3. Media reports the costings were done in a fashion that is actually illegal, and screws it all up, leaving Depts in a precarious position
-
4. Treasury,Finance & PBO release statements on those media “reports” today, clarifying what was already obvious to anyone with room temp IQ
-
5. Media misses the point that *they* fucked up and caused it – because that could never happen dhaaaarling – and go down the rabbit hole
-
6. So now it’s not the fact that they were ignorant politards that fucked it up, but outrage that gov did what gov said they did. o_O
-
And that’s where we are at. Welcome to the sausage factory of elections.
-
@Pollytics Too true. It would wonderful to be such an expert on everything …like so many writing comment on Parkinson & Tune statement
-
Hhmm. Easy to see them unashamed bias of those interpreting Parkinson/Tune statement as a “slap down” for govt. Black is white/ up is down
-
Wow! The amount of misunderstanding of Treasury & Finance is extraordinary. Has anyone actually read the Statement?
-
Hands up all the journos writing about the budget costings that have worked in Treasury or Finance? What? None? There’s a surprise
-
Here’s all the documents for those that haven’t seen them bit.ly/12OLmOr
-
@Pollytics So which journalist will take responsibility for distorting, misrepresenting after they just wallowed in Gov “mistake” again?
-
-
Interesting that tonight no-one has provided any evidence that LNP costings are correct.
-
The problem was that Rudd/Wong/Bowen didn’t put the gallery in high chairs, stick bibs on them & feed them the info with aeroplane noises
-
@GrogsGamut This election coverage is worse than last time -and this time the pollies are not to blame